Mar 18, 2024

Is SEO Worth It? A Wise Investment or a Waste of Money

Vaishnavi Ramkumar
Is SEO Worth It? A Wise Investment or a Waste of Money
Vaishnavi Ramkumar
Mar 18, 2024

Is SEO Worth It? A Wise Investment or a Waste of Money

Get the answer to 'is SEO worth it' for your business. Is it a smart move or a costly mistake? Learn more on our blog.
Is SEO Worth It? A Wise Investment or a Waste of Money

Table of contents

SEO is often contemplated as a costly venture. Its true value lies in the long-term benefits it offers which might not be instantly visible to businesses. Unlike the immediate outcomes seen with paid advertising, SEO may not guarantee a top spot in Google's rankings, but it does provide sustained visibility in the ever-changing digital landscape. SEO also lacks a comprehensive performance dashboard that spells out how your daily expenditure translates into increased revenue. With apparent complexity, businesses sometimes hesitate to consider it. But data tells a different story, SEO is indeed worth the investment in 2023 and beyond.

Understanding SEO and Its Importance

SEO, a cost-effective marketing tactic, generates awareness, high-quality traffic, and conversions for businesses. It goes beyond brand recognition, building trust among prospects. It capitalizes on organic search potential, bringing disproportionate increases in website traffic and correspondingly, leads at every stage of the customer journey. This lays the foundation for a strong business case to invest in SEO.

The basics of SEO

SEO begins with effective website optimization for search engines. It involves keyword research, meta tags, URL structuring, and other technical aspects. Optimizing website architecture makes it user-friendly and easy to index for search engines. Complementing this, content optimization involves curating informative, valuable, and keyword-optimized content that resonates with the target audience. Backlink building forms the third pillar of successful SEO campaigns, with an emphasis on obtaining high-quality backlinks from credible sources. Regularly monitoring and refining these aspects in line with evolving SEO trends is the backbone of effective SEO management.

Organic search vs. paid search

Paid search drives website traffic through advertisements, which require continuous investment for maintaining visibility. On the other hand, organic search depends on strategic SEO inputs, ensuring sustained visibility without additional costs. Although paid search can provide immediate visibility on the search engine result pages (SERPs), the traffic drops significantly once you stop funding the ads. Organic search, however, focuses on growing traffic steadily over time. It comprises people actively seeking information related to your products or services, making it an evergreen source of potential customers.

Why businesses need SEO

SEO fuels digital growth for businesses by offering multifaceted benefits:

  • Brand Visibility: When your website ranks higher in SERPs, it can attract a larger pool of prospects and increase brand recognition.
  • Credibility and Trust: Consistent high ranking translates into assumed credibility, as users trust Google's judgement.
  • Targeted Traffic: SEO brings in potential customers who are actively seeking information about your services, ultimately driving website traffic.
  • Cost-Efficiency: SEO doesn’t require payment for each click, helping in reducing customer acquisition costs.
  • User Experience: SEO processes like improving website speed and design contribute to superior user experience.

Factors Determining the Worth of SEO

Determining the value of SEO is influenced by various factors like business niche, competition, geographic reach, and target audience. Other critical aspects include business goals, objectives, and the level of engagement your product/service involves. Fine-tuning these factors significantly bolsters your SEO strategy.

Business niche and competition

Every business operates in a particular niche with specific needs and challenges. The level of competition within your niche directly affects your SEO strategy. High-competition markets require more robust and aggressive SEO strategies compared to those with less competition. Ecommerce, real estate, and healthcare are examples of highly competitive sectors where businesses need strong SEO to stand out.

On the other hand, if your business operates in a more uncommon or specific industry, such as falcon training or underwater basket weaving, you could potentially face less competition. In such cases, even simpler SEO measures can yield strong results. Therefore, identify your competition accurately and plan your SEO tactics accordingly.

Geographic reach and target audience

The geographic reach of your business significantly influences your SEO strategies. For instance, a local business targeting customers in a specific area may need to focus more on local SEO strategies to increase its visibility amongst the local population. This includes optimizing your website to rank high in local search results, producing localized content, and getting your business listed in local online directories.

Conversely, an ecommerce business targeting nationwide or global customers might focus on broader SEO strategies to target a more extensive geographic audience. You will need to optimize your website from both a technical and content perspective, focusing on a wide range of keywords relevant to your products or services. Understanding your target audience and optimizing your SEO strategies to reach them effectively is crucial for success.

SEO goals and objectives

Your business goals and objectives play an important role in shaping your SEO strategy. Various businesses could have different objectives, ranging from improving brand visibility and increasing website traffic to boosting sales or lead generation.

Goals SEO Tactics
Brand Visibility Focus on broad keywords, content marketing
Increase Traffic Keyword optimization, backlinking
Boost Sales Landing page optimization, CTA placement

Defining clear SEO objectives helps you measure the value of your SEO investment more accurately by aligning them with measurable key performance indicators (KPIs).

The ROI of SEO

Effective SEO activities offer significant return on investment by enhancing organic traffic, user experience, website performance, and leading to higher conversion rates. By targeting the right keywords, adopting good SEO practices, and continually improving your website's SEO, you can significantly increase your bottom line.

Increase in organic traffic

By enhancing your website's SEO, you can significantly boost your organic traffic. Organic traffic refers to visitors that arrive on your website as a result of unpaid search results. Organic search drives over half of all web traffic, making it an essential component of your digital marketing strategy. With optimized SEO strategies, you get more visibility on search engine results, increasing the chances of potential customers finding your site. This organic traffic isn’t just high-volume, it’s also targeted. That means these are people who are actively seeking the products or services you offer, thereby increasing the likelihood of conversion.

Improved user experience and website performance

SEO is not just about keywords and backlinks; it also involves enhancing the overall user experience on your site. Factors like site loading speed, mobile-friendliness, easy navigation, and high-quality content all play a role in user experience, and they’re all elements that search engines factor into their rankings.

Improvements in these areas not only boost your site's SEO but also result in a better user experience, which can improve engagement and increase conversions. Moreover, by monitoring user behavior data, you can get insights into visitor's preferences and behaviors, allowing for further improvements and optimization.

Higher conversion rates

SEO leads have a 14.6% close rate, compared to only 1.7% for outbound leads such as print ads. This illustrates the superiority of SEO in driving quality leads that translate into conversions. Good SEO puts your business in front of users at the exact moment they’re showing interest in your products or services, making them more likely to convert. By constantly optimizing your targeted keywords and creating high-quality content focused on these keywords, you can effectively reach out to your target audience, generate quality leads, and boost your conversion rate.

Real-life Examples of SEO Success

Several real-world examples demonstrate the significant rewards that good SEO practices can yield. Here, we’ll explore two detailed case studies of businesses that experienced tremendous growth and improvement in their overall performance through innovative SEO strategies.

Example 1

Home Restoration Roofing, a roofing company, invested in reimagining its online image and implementing on-page and off-page SEO tactics. They partnered with an SEO expert agency that helped them with:

  • A complete revamp of their website design and user interface.
  • Optimization of content with critical and relevant keywords.
  • Generating high-quality backlinks from reputable sources.

As a result, Restoration Roofing witnessed a surge in its organic traffic by 162%. Not only did they see an increase in traffic, but their conversion rates also quadrupled due to the website's makeover and improved user experience. This increase in traffic and conversions led to a substantial spike in their earnings, underlining that SEO was a solid investment for the company.

Example 2, a popular weather forecasting website, made a significant impact using video markup SEO strategy. Producing daily video content, they implemented video markup on all relevant pages. This strategic move:

  • Accelerated their indexing process.
  • Optimized their videos to appear in search results.
  • Increased the visibility of their video content on google SERPs.

This efficient SEO strategy helped double the number of their indexed pages, increasing daily traffic and significantly enhancing advertising revenues. This case reveals how innovative SEO methods can be applied to drive success even in niche sectors like weather forecasting.

Addressing Common Myths and Objections to SEO

Despite numerous success stories, several myths and objections deter businesses from investing in SEO. Some of the common misconceptions include the perception that SEO is too expensive, results take too long, or relies on untrustworthy tactics. Let's delve into these myths and provide clarity on the importance and viability of SEO.

SEO is too expensive

It's a prevalent belief that SEO services come at a high cost. However, it’s critical to understand that while SEO does require an upfront investment, in the long run, it's far more cost-effective than other marketing methods like paid ads. The average cost of SEO services varies based on your specific needs and objectives, but remember, you often get what you pay for. Opting for cheaper SEO can lead to subpar results and even penalties from Google.

While SEO costs may seem high, it’s important to weigh them against the potential ROI. The ongoing benefits of improved web traffic and increased conversions far outweigh the initial SEO investment, making it a cost-effective marketing strategy that provides a significant return in the long run.

Results take too long

Another common criticism of SEO is that results take too long to materialize. The truth is, SEO is more of a marathon than a sprint. It isn't a 'set it and forget it' marketing tactic. It requires persistent work, time, and patience to bear results. But once it takes off, the results can be remarkable.

An effective SEO strategy typically begins to show significant improvements in rankings and traffic about six to eight months after implementation. From there, you can expect steady improvement as long as you continue investing in your SEO efforts. Remember, the average webpage ranking on the first page of Google is more than two years old, emphasizing the fact that SEO is a long-term investment.

The use of shady tactics

Unfortunately, in the SEO industry, there are companies making false promises and using black hat SEO techniques. These misleading methods can backfire, leading to severe penalties from search engines and even de-indexing of your site entirely.

However, this doesn’t mean all SEO is unreliable. Many trusted SEO agencies adhere to white hat strategies in line with Google's guidelines. To ensure you choose a reputable agency, check for industry recognition, client testimonials, case studies, and online reviews. Never choose an agency making outlandish guarantees of instant top rankings. Quality SEO takes time and involves a strategic, multifaceted approach.


In conclusion, SEO certainly warrants the investment, given the multitude of benefits it brings to your online business. By leveraging SEO effectively, you can achieve enhanced website visibility, better brand recognition, more organic traffic, and improved conversion rates. When deciding on the value of SEO for your business, consider your business niche, target audience, geographical reach, as well as business goals and objectives. With all myths and misconceptions addressed, one can unequivocally state that SEO plays a crucial role in shaping a business’s online presence and potential for growth. If implemented strategically, in accordance with Google's guidelines and best practices, SEO can yield exceptional long term returns, far outweighing its initial cost.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is SEO worth it for small businesses?

Absolutely! Small businesses can greatly benefit from SEO by gaining visibility, reaching a larger customer base, and standing out among local competitors. With the right strategies, even small-scale operations can achieve significant online presence and growth through SEO.

How long does it take to see results from SEO?

Seeing notable results from SEO generally takes around six to eight months of consistent effort. Remember, SEO is not an overnight game; it requires patience and long-term dedication. Results will steadily improve over time with continued SEO efforts.

Can I do SEO myself, or should I hire an SEO agency?

While anyone can learn and implement SEO strategies, hiring an SEO agency provides expertise, experience, and resources to execute highly effective SEO campaigns. If you’re new to SEO or running a business with limited time and resources, hiring an SEO agency may be more worthwhile.

Vaishnavi Ramkumar
Content Marketer
ABout the AUTHOR
Vaishnavi Ramkumar
Content Marketer

Vaishnavi Ramkumar is a content marketer specializing in creating BOFU content for SaaS brands. She believes reader-centric content is the sure-shot way to generate high-quality leads through content marketing. As part of the Scalenut team, Vaishnavi curates content that drives brand awareness and boosts signups. When she's not crafting content, you can find her immersed in the pages of a good book or a course.

View all articles by this Author -->
Thank you!
Our Product Specialist will connect with you shortly. In the meanwhile, please explore Scalenut
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Free content strategy call with expert
Free content strategy call with expert
Strategy with an all-in-one SEO solution
Get a personalized demo of Scalenut’s features
Showcase practical business use cases your whole team can use.
Learn about pricing options for your use case
Schedule Demo
Create SEO-Ready Blog with Scalenut
Try Scalenut for Free
Boost Your SEO Game